In this post, Monna Matharu, Access & Participation Impact Officer, reflects on two evaluation reports examining our financial support published by the APP Impact Team.
Earlier this month, the Higher Education Policy Institute published a blog from JS Group, a provider of payment services for university bursaries and scholarships. It asked whether universities are making a difference with the financial support they provide. Drawing on four years of activity across more than 45 institutions and feedback from 5,000 students, it highlights three points: when support arrives, how much control students have over it, and the capacity it creates to take part in university life.
Last year, Bath published two evaluation reports on student financial support. Produced by the Impact team as part of the ten research projects in our Access and Participation Plan (APP), they speak to the same questions. Students told us that financial support gave them security and independence, but that its value dependent on how comfortable they felt using it, and on the wider costs they faced. In this blog we’ve drawn out four themes that cut across our two reports on student financial support; Bath Bursary and Cost of Living.
Two evaluations, two lenses
The Bath Bursary evaluation looked closely at one scheme and asked four questions. Does the Bursary ease financial concerns? Does it affect student wellbeing, university experience and belonging? Is there any link with continuation? And how do students feel about how it's paid? We followed the Office for Students' Financial Support Evaluation Toolkit and combined three strands. First, we analysed continuation to second year data for 12,852 students across four entry cohorts (2020/21 to 2023/24), comparing Bursary recipients with middle- and high-income peers. Second, we ran a survey in 2023/24 with 319 Year 1 and final-year students, including middle-income comparators. Third, we interviewed 15 recipients in March 2025, drawn from nearly 190 who volunteered. The statistics and survey reflect the Bursary in its earlier, all-cash format. The interviews also picked up views on its 2024/25 changes.
The cost-of-living evaluation took a wider view. Rather than looking at one scheme, we asked how undergraduates experience the cost of living. We held ten one-to-one interviews in spring 2025, again drawn from nearly 190 volunteers. We chose students from across the household income range, though the sample leaned towards lower incomes. The backdrop was stark: in 2025, private rents in Bath and North East Somerset reached £1,761 a month (up 9% on the year), South West students reported the second-highest average monthly spend in the country (£1,193), and the average maintenance loan was estimated to fall around £500 a month short of living costs.
Support that gives students room to breathe
For Bursary recipients, the headline numbers were encouraging. In our survey, 88% said it helped them pay essential living costs and 52% said it allowed them to live more comfortably. Around 87% felt more satisfied with their life as a student, 86% felt less anxious than they otherwise would have, and 81% said it was important or very important to their ability to continue studying.
The interviews showed what those percentages mean day to day. One student said, "It's made me feel a lot more secure. I know that if something goes wrong that I will have money coming in to help me out" (Bursary evaluation). Another valued the independence that the Bursary provides: "it's given me that freedom to kind of live independently and not have to rely on money from others" (Bursary evaluation). Several students also spoke about easing the burden on their families. As one put it, "It eased the stress a lot. Not only for me, but also I guess probably for my parents" (Bursary evaluation).
The Bursary also changed how much students needed to work. Recipients were less likely than comparators to rely on money from family or friends (33% vs 46%). One described the relief of realising "I won't have to work as much anymore. Focus on my studies. Focus on socialising" (Bursary evaluation).
Valued, but not the whole story
The picture on continuation was more complicated. In every cohort we examined, Bursary recipients continued to second year at slightly lower rates than middle-income peers. In 2023/24, the figures were 90.9% for recipients, 94.0% for middle-income students and 96.3% for high-income students. Bath's continuation rates overall are high, exceeding the sector average by 8.3 percentage points between 2019/20 and 2022/23. The gap remained after we accounted for area deprivation, ethnicity, disability, gender, age, faculty and year of entry.
We're careful about what this means. It doesn't suggest the Bursary isn't helping. Students strongly value it, and many described it as essential to staying at Bath. But it does suggest that financial support may not be enough on its own to overcome the effects of disadvantage, and that other, non-financial barriers may be at play. As the report acknowledges, middle-income students bring their own advantages and pressures, and we couldn't create a control group, so this comparison needs careful reading.
Money shapes belonging, often quietly
On the headline belonging measure, recipients looked much like their peers: 69% agreed "I feel like I belong at Bath", compared with 71% of comparators. More recipients felt valued as an individual (56% vs 43%). But fewer felt they had a network of peers who understood their values and background (58% vs 67%).
The interviews added texture that the survey couldn't. One recipient told us, "I don't mention to anyone I actually have the bursary just because I don't feel comfortable […] I don't want to be pitied" (Bursary evaluation). Another felt very differently: "I felt completely comfortable really because for me it's not something to be ashamed of. I'm just lucky that I can be here" (Bursary evaluation).
The cost-of-living interviews showed how money can shape friendships. "I don't go out as often as others want, then it's just slowly, slowly not inviting [me to] things like that" (Cost-of-living evaluation). Students described skipping social events, choosing free or cheap ways to meet up, and weighing up the cost of sports and societies. One decided against a ball at the Roman Baths because "I just in my head couldn't justify" the £25 ticket (Cost-of-living evaluation). We can't attribute belonging scores to the Bursary alone, but it's clear that what money buys, and what it stops students joining in with, matters.
The costs outside the award, and the work that fills the gap
In the cost-of-living interviews, students consistently pointed to accommodation, transport and food. One said, "Rent in Bath is extortionate, and the fact that you'd get the same amount of maintenance loan if you're living in Bath as if you're living in Lincoln" (Cost-of-living evaluation).
Transport affected whether students came to campus at all: "The bus is £4.30 to go to uni and back. That's the price of 3-4 meals just to be able to go on campus and do my degree" (Cost-of-living evaluation). Another described food costs creeping up: "I used to be able to go to the shop, spend £20 on food and that would last me the week. Now it cost me like fifty" (Cost-of-living evaluation). Even with the full maintenance loan and a bursary, one student said they were "very much at my limit" (Cost-of-living evaluation).
Students also noticed and valued what the University had done, including £1.50 meals, a community larder and price-locks on campus: "there are really good initiatives" (Cost-of-living evaluation).
Paid work was often a necessity, not a choice. In the Bursary survey, 73% of students who worked said it was to cover essential living costs, and recipients who worked were more likely than comparators to be doing 15 or more hours a week (20% vs 12%). (Bursary survey). Students described the cost of this plainly: “if I don’t get money then I can’t really do uni. So, it’s very cyclical” (Cost-of-living evaluation). Quality mattered as much as quantity. One student left a restaurant job because the shifts were so rigid and moved to a university role because “they’re really casual” (Cost-of-living evaluation).
Student voice is the key
The Bath Bursary evaluation combined statistical analysis, survey data and interviews, while the cost-of-living evaluation focused on qualitative interviews. Together, these approaches demonstrate the value of looking at both the scale of financial pressures and the individual experiences behind them.
The numbers told us a continuation gap exists and roughly how big it is. However, it was speaking directly to students which allowed us to unpick the story behind the numbers: stigma about asking for help, the bus-fare arithmetic behind every social plan, and long working hours to supplement financial support. The data shows us how many students are affected by the cost-of -living crisis, but it is the interviews across both projects that paint the fuller picture.
We closed interviews across both projects by asking whether Bath has got its support right and what advice students would give to improve it, and those answers shaped what we took forward. HEPI’s call to move from delivering support to designing it for impact is one we echo. Our two evaluations suggest that students are often best placed to tell us whether support is landing, and that building the most effective financial support package starts with hearing directly from those who need it most.
What's next
If you’re interested in where financial support evaluation is heading, here’s what we’re watching across the sector.
Nationally, policy has moved on since our fieldwork. Maintenance loans will now rise with forecast inflation, and from 2028/29 grants of up to £1,000 a year are due to return for low-income students on courses aligned with the government’s priorities. Institutional support will complement national provision, so understanding how it works, and for whom, remains as important as ever.
TASO has opened a call for independent evaluators to work with three higher education providers, assessing the impact of their undergraduate financial support schemes using retrospective quasi-experimental designs. Find out more and apply on the TASO website.
Want to read the full reports? Access the Bath Bursary evaluation here and the Cost of Living evaluation here.
Want to see what else we are working on? Explore our other evaluation projects here.
Want to reach out to the evaluation team? Contact appimpact@bath.ac.uk.